Email marketing: what it is and when it works

Email marketing is the use of messages sent to people who gave you their address, in order to turn them into customers, help them start using the product and keep them coming back. It rarely finds strangers on its own. Its strength is moving people you already reached one step further, from visitor to trial, from trial to habit, from habit to renewal.

When it works

  • It works for almost any company that has a steady trickle of signups, trials or leads, because it multiplies the value of attention you already earned.
  • It earns its place early, as soon as people sign up but do not finish setup, since a few well timed messages can rescue users who would otherwise drift away.
  • It helps most with products bought on a subscription or reordered often, where keeping a customer matters as much as winning one.
  • You need a list of people who opted in, basic event tracking so emails can react to what users do, and a clear idea of the first action that makes the product stick.

When it usually fails

  • Every subscriber gets the same newsletter on the same day regardless of what they have done, so the messages feel like noise and get ignored.
  • The list is bought or scraped, which harms deliverability and lands your future emails in spam folders for everyone.
  • Emails push upgrades before the user has seen any value, which teaches people to stop opening them.

Three experiments to test it

  1. Nudge users who stall in setup

    7.3
    ICE

    If we send a short, plain email the day after a user stops partway through setup, then your activation rate will rise because the message removes the one step they got stuck on.

    Metric
    your activation rate
    Impact
    8
    Confidence
    7
    Ease
    7
  2. Send from a person, not a brand

    7.3
    ICE

    If we send the welcome email as plain text from a founder with a direct question, then replies to the welcome email will increase because it reads like a note from someone who wants an answer.

    Metric
    replies to the welcome email
    Impact
    5
    Confidence
    7
    Ease
    10
  3. Win back quiet customers

    5.3
    ICE

    If we email customers who have not logged in for a few weeks with one specific thing they have not tried, then your returning user count will grow because a concrete reason to come back beats a generic reminder.

    Metric
    returning users from dormant accounts
    Impact
    6
    Confidence
    4
    Ease
    6

How to tell if it is working

The metric to watch
the share of new signups who complete the key first action
Test length
two weeks

Open rates are a weak signal, so watch what people do in the product after the email arrives. Compare a group that got the message with one that did not.

Related channels

Find out where Email marketing ranks for your company.