Community building: what it is and when it works

Community building is the work of connecting your users to one another, through forums, chat groups, local chapters or shared projects, so they get value from each other and not just from you. Members answer questions, share what they built and bring in peers. Growth comes from that shared identity, which makes people stay longer and talk about you more. The company's job is to start the conversation, then step back and let members carry it.

When it works

  • Your users share a craft or a role and want to learn from each other, such as developers, designers, creators or operators.
  • You already have a core group of engaged users who would show up even if you posted nothing.
  • Your product gets better when users swap templates, plugins, tips or workflows with each other.
  • You can commit to it for many months, since a community grows slowly before it grows on its own.

When it usually fails

  • You open a forum before anyone cares, and the empty space signals that the product has no following.
  • The team does all the talking, so members treat the space as a support desk instead of a group of peers.
  • Nobody moderates, spam and off-topic posts pile up, and the best members leave quietly without ever telling you why.

Three experiments to test it

  1. Invite the first members by hand

    7.0
    ICE

    If we personally invite our most active users into a private group before opening it up, then weekly posts will rise because early members set the tone and keep it lively.

    Metric
    weekly member posts
    Impact
    7
    Confidence
    7
    Ease
    7
  2. Spotlight member work

    6.3
    ICE

    If we feature one member's project each week in the group and in our newsletter, then member referrals will grow because people share the places that celebrate them.

    Metric
    new members from referrals
    Impact
    6
    Confidence
    5
    Ease
    8
  3. Hand over a recurring event

    5.3
    ICE

    If we let trusted members run a monthly call or challenge, then retention for community members will improve because they feel ownership, not just access.

    Metric
    your retention for community members
    Impact
    8
    Confidence
    4
    Ease
    4

How to tell if it is working

The metric to watch
Questions answered by members, not staff
Test length
three months

A healthy community answers itself, so watch the share of replies that come from members over time. Compare retention for members and non-members to see whether the community is keeping people around. Expect slow numbers early and look for the trend, not a single good week.

Related channels

Find out where Community building ranks for your company.