Search engine marketing: what it is and when it works

Search engine marketing is paying to show ads on search engines when people type queries that suggest they want what you sell. You bid on keywords, pay when someone clicks and send them to a page built for that query. Because the searcher already has the need, it is one of the most direct ways to buy customers, as long as each customer is worth more than the clicks it took to win them.

When it works

  • It suits products people already search for by name of the problem, such as software categories, local services and online stores.
  • It is useful early as a fast way to test messages and later as a steady source of customers once the numbers hold up.
  • Higher priced or high margin products have more room to absorb the cost of clicks that never buy.
  • You need conversion tracking in place, a landing page per theme, a list of negative keywords to block poor matches and a clear idea of what a customer is worth to you.

When it usually fails

  • Nobody searches for the problem yet, because your category is new and people do not know to look for it.
  • Large competitors bid on the same terms, pushing the price of a click above what a customer is worth.
  • Every ad points to the home page, so searchers do not see the answer to the query they typed and leave before reading further.

Three experiments to test it

  1. Long tail keyword set

    7.0
    ICE

    If we bid on specific, longer queries instead of broad category terms, then cost per signup will fall because narrow searches carry clearer intent and attract fewer competing bids.

    Metric
    cost per signup
    Impact
    7
    Confidence
    7
    Ease
    7
  2. Matching landing pages

    6.0
    ICE

    If we send each ad group to a page whose headline repeats the searcher's query, then your conversion rate from paid search will rise because visitors see at once that they landed in the right place.

    Metric
    your conversion rate from paid search
    Impact
    7
    Confidence
    6
    Ease
    5
  3. Competitor comparison ads

    5.0
    ICE

    If we run ads on searches that compare alternatives in our category, then trial starts will grow because people comparing options are close to a decision and want a clear reason to pick one.

    Metric
    trial starts
    Impact
    5
    Confidence
    4
    Ease
    6

How to tell if it is working

The metric to watch
Cost per paying customer
Test length
four weeks

Judge the channel on paying customers, not clicks or signups, since cheap clicks can hide expensive customers. Start with a small daily budget and widen it only once the cost per customer stays below what a customer earns you.

Related channels

Find out where Search engine marketing ranks for your company.