Offline ads: what it is and when it works

Offline ads are paid messages in physical and broadcast media: television, radio, print publications, billboards, transit posters and direct mail. They reach audiences that online ads often miss, such as older buyers, local communities and people who listen while driving. They are harder to track, so the work is as much about measuring response as it is about buying the space.

When it works

  • Local businesses and products for audiences that spend less time online gain the most from offline placements.
  • It usually comes after a company has proven its offer online and wants a new pool of buyers.
  • Products with a high lifetime value can carry the cost of broad reach, while cheap one time purchases rarely can.
  • You need a simple offer, a memorable web address or code, a page that greets people arriving from the ad and a way to tell offline responses apart from everything else.

When it usually fails

  • There is no unique code, number or address, so you cannot tell whether any signups came from the ad or would have happened anyway.
  • You buy a large national placement first instead of testing a small local one, and the money is gone before you learn anything.
  • The message tries to say too much, when people glancing at a billboard or half listening to radio remember one idea at most, ideally your name and why it matters to them.

Three experiments to test it

  1. Local radio test

    4.7
    ICE

    If we run a short spot on a single local radio station with a unique web address, then visits to that address will rise because listeners who drive often look things up once they stop.

    Metric
    visits to the unique address
    Impact
    5
    Confidence
    4
    Ease
    5
  2. Direct mail to a tight list

    5.0
    ICE

    If we mail a simple card with a personal code to a narrow list of likely buyers, then code redemptions will grow because a physical piece in hand gets more attention than another email.

    Metric
    code redemptions
    Impact
    6
    Confidence
    5
    Ease
    4
  3. Remnant print space

    5.0
    ICE

    If we buy unsold, last minute space in a trade magazine our buyers read, then inbound leads will rise because the audience is focused and discounted space lowers the risk of the test.

    Metric
    inbound leads
    Impact
    4
    Confidence
    5
    Ease
    6

How to tell if it is working

The metric to watch
Responses tied to a unique code or address
Test length
six weeks

Offline ads build slowly, so give each placement enough time and compare it with a similar period without the ad. Also watch branded searches, since many people will look you up instead of typing the exact code.

Related channels

Find out where Offline ads ranks for your company.